Product Description
Table of Contents
Additional Information
This is the first book to offer an extensive cosmopolitan, cross-cultural insight into the perennial controversy over the use of improperly obtained evidence in criminal trials. It challenges the conventional view that exclusionary rules are idiosyncratic of Anglo-American law, and highlights the 'constitutionalisation' and 'internationalisation' of criminal evidence and procedure as a cause of rapprochement (or divergence) beyond the Anglo-American and Continental law divide. Analysis focuses on confessional evidence and evidence obtained by search and seizure, telephone interceptions and other means of electronic surveillance. The laws of England and Wales, France, Greece and the United States are systematically compared and contrasted throughout this study, but, where appropriate, analysis extends to other Anglo-American and Continental legal systems. The book reviews exclusionary rules vis-a-vis the operation of judicial discretion, and explores the normative justifications that underpin them. It attempts to reinvigorate the idea of excluding evidence to protect constitutional or human rights (the rights thesis), arguing that there is significant scope for Anglo-American and Continental legal systems to place a renewed emphasis on it, particularly in relation to confessional evidence obtained in violation of custodial interrogation rights; we can locate an emerging rapprochement, and unique potential for European Court of Human Rights jurisprudence to build consensus in this respect. In marked contrast, remaining divergence with regard to evidence obtained by privacy violations means there is little momentum to adopt a reinvigorated rights thesis more widely. Longlisted for the Inner Temple Book Prize 2022.
1. Introduction I. Four Comparative Law Pillars II. Linguistics III. Who Excludes? IV. At What Stage of the Process is Evidence Excluded? V. What Happens after Exclusion? VI. Organisation of the Book 2. Exclusionary Rules for Evidence Obtained in Violation of the Right to Privacy: Greece and the United States I. Prolegomena on the Link Between Constitutionalisation and Automatic Exclusionary Rules II. Reading the Exclusionary Rule into the Constitution III. Constitutional Exclusionary Rules IV. The Greek Exclusionary Rule for Evidence Obtained by the Commission of Criminal Offences V. Same Origins, Different Directions: The Deterrent and Protective Rationales in Action VI. Caveats VII. Concluding Thoughts VIII. Epilogue: Triggers for the Constitutionalisation of the Exclusionary Rule 3. Discretionary Exclusion of Evidence Obtained in Violation of the Right to Privacy: France and England and Wales I. General Principles and Legislative Framework II. Jurisprudential Applications: Admitting Evidence Obtained in Violation of the Right to Privacy III. Evidence Obtained Through the Bugging of Police Cells: French Lessons for England and Wales? IV. Concluding Thoughts 4. Improperly Obtained Confessional Evidence: Converging Rights-Based Approaches I. The Modern Metamorphoses of the French Nullites of the Garde a Vue: The Road to Automatic Nullities II. Automatic Nullities for Violations of Suspects' Rights in Greece III. Miranda v Arizona: The Exclusionary Rule in Fast Decline (but Exclusion is Still Automatic) IV. Confessional Evidence, Reliability and Suspects' Rights: A Mixed Picture in the UK V. Concluding Thoughts 5. Confessional Evidence and European Court of Human Rights Jurisprudence: Building Rights-based Consensus or Backtracking on Rights Protection? I. The European Court of Human Rights' Miranda Moment: The Salduz Jurisprudence II. From Salduz's Exclusionary Rule to Common Custodial Interrogation Rights in Europe (Passing by the EU Procedural Rights Directives) III. Throwing Salduz 'Off the Rails'? IV. Concluding Thoughts 6. Reinvigorating the Rights Thesis I. Improperly Obtained Evidence and the Aims of the Criminal Process II. 'Excluding Evidence as Protecting Rights' Revisited III. Is There Support in Comparative Law for the Rights Thesis? IV. Concluding Thoughts 7. Epilogue: The Future
Author(s) | By Dimitrios Giannoulopoulos. |
---|---|
Publisher | Bloomsbury Publishing PLC |
ISBN | 9781849463829 |
Format | Hardback |
Pages | 328 |
Published in | United Kingdom |
Published | 21 Feb 2019 |
Availability | Available |
Practice Area
-
Company, commercial & competition
- Agency law
- Aviation law
- Commercial law
- Company law
- Company, commercial & competition law
- Competition law \ Antitrust law
- Construction & engineering law
- Contract law
- E-commerce law
- Energy & natural resources law
- Franchising law
- Outsourcing law
- Partnership law
- Procurement law
- Sale of goods law
- Shipping law
-
Constitutional & administrative
- Asylum law
- Citizenship & nationality law
- Constitutional & administrative law
- Election law
- Freedom of expression law
- Freedom of information law
- Government powers
- Human rights & civil liberties law
- Immigration law
- Judicial review
- Local government law
- Military & defence law
- Parliamentary & legislative practice
- Privacy law
-
Criminal law & procedure
- Criminal justice law
- Criminal law & procedures
- Criminal procedure
- Criminal procedure: law of evidence
- Fraud
- Harassment law
- Juvenile criminal law
- Offences against property
- Offences against public health, safety, order
- Offences against the government
- Offences against the person
- Police law & police procedures
- Road traffic law, motoring offences
- Sentencing & punishment
- Terrorism law
- Employment & labour
- Environment, transport & planning
- Equity & trusts
- Family
- Financial
- IT & Communications
- Intellectual property
-
International
- Customary law
- Diplomatic law
- International
- International arbitration
- International communications & telecommunications law
- International courts & procedures
- International criminal law
- International economic & trade law
- International environmental law
- International human rights law
- International humanitarian law
- International law
- International law of territory & statehood
- International law of transport, communications & commerce
- International law reports
- International maritime law
- International organisations & institutions
- International space & aerospace law
- Investment treaties & disputes
- Jurisdiction & immunities
- Law of the sea
- Private international law & conflict of laws
- Public international law
- Responsibility of states & other entities
- Settlement of international disputes
- Tariffs
- Transnational commercial law
- Treaties & other sources of international law
-
Jurisprudence & general
- Advocacy
- Civil codes \ Civil law
- Common law
- Comparative law
- Criminology: legal aspects
- Ecclesiastical (canon) law
- Gender & the law
- Islamic law
- Jurisprudence & general issues
- Jurisprudence & philosophy of law
- Law & society
- Law as it applies to other professions
- Legal ethics & professional conduct
- Legal history
- Legal profession: general
- Legal skills & practice
- Paralegals & paralegalism
- Roman law
- Systems of law
- Law - other
- Law: study & revision guides
- Laws of Specific jurisdictions
-
Legal system
- Arbitration, mediation & alternative dispute resolution
- Civil procedure, litigation & dispute resolution
- Civil procedure: law of evidence
- Civil remedies
- Courts & procedure
- Damages & compensation
- Injunctions & other orders
- Judicial powers
- Legal system: costs & funding
- Legal system: general
- Legal system: law of contempt
- Regulation of legal profession
- Restitution
- Primary sources
- Private \ Civil law: general works
- Property
- Social
- Taxation & duties
- Torts & Delicts
- Wills & probate \ Succession
My Cart
You have no items in your shopping cart.